Hey solent, are you gonna address my valid concerns? I have worked in PT offices and have a close friendship with two DPTs, so I truly enjoy this subject and feel this would be a good thread to hash out the outdated and dangerous recommendations of yesteryear's PTs.
So most physical therapists who specialize in athletics understand the stupidity of static stretching before anything explosive or physically demanding in any way. They've understood for years now the benefits of dynamic stretching pre-workload. It just looks like warmups to your average joe, but it's dynamic stretching.
What are your qualifications to tell us that we should be doing what has been proven to be both detrimental to muscle tissue (micro-tears as POB said, and not the kind you want from training) AND joint stability?
So most physical therapists who specialize in athletics understand the stupidity of static stretching before anything explosive or physically demanding in any way. They've understood for years now the benefits of dynamic stretching pre-workload. It just looks like warmups to your average joe, but it's dynamic stretching.
What are your qualifications to tell us that we should be doing what has been proven to be both detrimental to muscle tissue (micro-tears as POB said, and not the kind you want from training) AND joint stability?
I am a fully qualified and accredited sports and remedial massage therapist. I have been lucky enough to be involved in many study classes on cadavers, keep my CPD up to date on various techniques and work with athletes and regular people with pain and injury issues.
I have been lifting myself since I was 16 and continue to do so In to my 40's...I have learned more through my own personal experiences than any text book or qualification could teach me. So I am certainly no arm chair warrior.
The context of my opinion is based on bodybuilders and weight lifters, hence my posts in the iron den. The study's out in the Internet could be useful and more concerned with professional athletes who need every percentage of power and speed to gain an advantage in their field.
As body builders/lifters who punish our body's up to 6 days a week lifting heavy stuff, our muscular structures are constantly tight and sore. To jump straight into a squat for example without stretching puts the knee in danger of injury, damage to ligaments and tendons etc. While warming up gets blood into the tissue and helps prevent injury in the muscle it does not get the muscle fibres back to their optimal length, reducing the pressure on tendons and joints.
We tend to over complicate things by reading conflicting study's that talk about percentage losses in strength but fail to realise the stupidity of worrying about percentage loss of strength rather than injury prevention.
Dorian Yates in blood and guts shows a good time spent stretching and warming up before leg day. This was down to experience and past injury, not because a text book told him to do it.
If I get a niggle in my knees during squats...I will immediately rack the weight, stretch off my quads and get back in with the knee pain gone. The patella has settled back into the correct position and my ligaments are not as tight as they were before the stretch. I will do this through all of my workout and will finish with stretches, Pilates/yoga movements etc. my intention is to be in the gym until I drop down dead and I couldn't do that without proper functioning muscle fibres.
My point in all of this is we are always tight and sore as bodybuilders/weight lifters etc..... a percentage of strength loss is far less valuable than injury prevention.
There are currently 0 members watching this topic